Please note: You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please update to IE10 here to properly experience the ATI website.

59.

Germany – Foreign Office

Very Poor

ATI_Donor Graph-59

OVERVIEW

See Germany-wide commitments and recommendations.

The Foreign Office (Auswärtiges Amt) is responsible for Germany’s foreign policy. In the field of development cooperation, it is responsible for humanitarian aid and support for human rights. The AA works with several implementing agencies, including GIZ, THW (Bundesanstalt Technisches Hilfswerk), German NGOs and other partners.

The AA is committed to implementing IATI by the end of 2015. It has not yet begun implementation; however, it is included in Germany’s July 2013 common standard implementation schedule. It does not publish a transparency or disclosure policy, though it cites Germany’s FOI legislation.

ANALYSIS

The AA scores 10.0%, placing it in the very poor category. It ranks 41st out of 49 bilateral organisations, scoring on just two activity-level indicators – MoUs and contact details. It publishes no other information at the activity level on a systematic basis. No comprehensive list of activities could be found on the AA’s website or the websites of the implementing agencies listed by the AA. At the organisation level, it does not publish annual reports, forward budgets for recipient countries or its procurement policy. Of the 22 indicators that take format into account, none are published by the AA in machine-readable formats and only two – contact details and one year forward-looking organisation budget – are published in other formats. Overall, it does not score on 30 of the 39 indicators included in the Index.

RECOMMENDATIONS

  • The AA should work with BMZ to complete an implementation schedule by early 2014 to address the AA’s specific institutional challenges and opportunities. It should begin implementation of IATI in 2014, so it can aim for full implementation of the IATI standard by the end of 2015.
  • It should engage with other ministries and agencies with which it works in development cooperation to ensure that Germany’s IATI publication includes a coherent and full picture of the activities and funds for which the AA is responsible.

Close

DONOR PROFILE

First published to IATI:

N/A

Data was found in the following formats where relevant:

0% IATI

0% CSV/Excel

0% PDF

9% Website

91% Not Published

SCORING

10.04%

COMMITMENT TO
AID TRANSPARENCY:

2.11/10

PUBLICATION
ORGANISATION LEVEL:

6.3/25

PUBLICATION
ACTIVITY LEVEL:

1.63/65

Commitment

1. FOIA

2. Implementation Schedules

3. Accessibility

Publication Status
Source

http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php

Comments

Global RTI rating score of 52. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using the following scale: 1 - 60: 33 61- 90: 66 91 - 150: 100.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

1. FOIA

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php
Global RTI rating score of 52. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using the following Expand...scale: 1 - 60: 33 61- 90: 66 91 - 150: 100

Donor Review
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php

PWYF Review
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php
Global RTI rating score of 52. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using the following Expand...scale: 1 - 60: 33 61- 90: 66 91 - 150: 100

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php
Global RTI rating score of 52. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using the Expand...following scale: 1 - 60: 33 61- 90: 66 91 - 150: 100.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://tracker.publishwhatyoufund.org/plan/organisations/

Comments

Based on Publish What You Fund's analysis of BMZ's updated IATI/Common Standard implementation schedule. The German version of the Common Standard implementation released by Germany, accessible at the BMZ website, also covers the Foreign Office.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

2. Implementation schedules

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
N/A
No Common Standard or IATI implementation schedule found for the AA. The Common Standard implementation schedule released by Germany does not Expand...seem to cover the Foreign Office. Implementation Schedules published before July 31 will be taken into consideration for the Index.

Donor Review
Document
N/A
The Common Standard implementation released by Germany, accessible at the BMZ website, also covers the Foreign Office (cp Part II - Expand...General questions - section 1 D) ii).

PWYF Review
https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CC0QFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.bmz.de%2Fen%2Fzentrales_downloadarchiv%2Fwege_und_akteure%2FTransparency%2FGermany_Common_Standard_Implementation_Schedule.xls&ei=0KfnUczKCdDu0gWqhoHACw&usg=AFQjCNHV0MrkYCr7-z5Vu-Dq22ijbwMDBQ&bvm=bv.49478099,d.d2k Expand...
The BMZ implementation schedule does not mention coverage of FO in the section highlighted by the donor.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Yes I agree, contact information given in the published iati data point only to the bmz.

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
http://tracker.publishwhatyoufund.org/plan/organisations/
Based on Publish What You Fund's analysis of BMZ's updated IATI/Common Standard implementation schedule. The German version of the Common Standard Expand...implementation released by Germany, accessible at the BMZ website, also covers the Foreign Office.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

No data available.

Comments

No portal or project database found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

3. Accessibility

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
N/A
No portal or project database found.

Donor Review
Document
N/A

PWYF Review
N/A
No portal or project database found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
No portal or project database found.

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
No portal or project database found.

Donor Comments

Planning

Financial

4. Organisation Strategy

5. Annual Report

6. Allocation Policy

7. Procurement Policy

8. Country Strategy

9. Total Budget

10. Disaggregated Budgets

11. Audit

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf

Comments

Strategy of the Federal Foreign Office for Humanitarian Assistance Abroad is available on the Foreign Office site.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

4. Organisation strategy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf
Strategy of the Federal Foreign Office for Humanitarian Assistance Abroad is available on the Foreign Office site.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf
Strategy of the Federal Foreign Office for Humanitarian Assistance Abroad is available on the Foreign Office site.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf
Strategy of the Federal Foreign Office for Humanitarian Assistance Abroad is available on the Foreign Office site.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

5. Annual report

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/WoHelfenWir_node.html

Comments

Allocation policy can be determined from the organisation strategy document and links on the website explaining where AA provides humanitarian aid

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

6. Allocation policy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/WoHelfenWir_node.html Expand...
Allocation policy can be determined from the organisation strategy document and links on the website explaining where AA provides humanitarian aid

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/WoHelfenWir_node.html Expand...
Allocation policy can be determined from the organisation strategy document and links on the website explaining where AA provides humanitarian aid

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/634144/publicationFile/177866/121115_AA-Strategie_humanitaere_hilfe.pdf http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/WoHelfenWir_node.html Expand...
Allocation policy can be determined from the organisation strategy document and links on the website explaining where AA provides humanitarian aid

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

There is no information on the AA website indicating that implementing organisations are responsible for procurement and publishing tenders.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

7. Procurement policy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
See my tender comment

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
There is no information on the AA website indicating that implementing organisations are responsible for procurement and publishing tenders.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/AktuelleArtikel/110506_HH_Brasilien_node.html

Comments

Although the information contained in the country pages is varied it is considered to be sufficiently detailed to score on this indicator because it provides information on both priority themes and sectors. This is consistent with what has been accepted for other donors for this indicator.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

8. Country strategy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/AktuelleArtikel/110506_HH_Brasilien_node.html Expand...
Some brief information on country strategies can be found in the different country pages on the 'where we work' section of Expand...the FO website. However the level of information varies and it is not always forward looking.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/AktuelleArtikel/110506_HH_Brasilien_node.html Expand...
Some brief information on country strategies can be found in the different country pages on the 'where we work' section of Expand...the FO website. However the level of information varies and it is not always forward looking.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
To my point of view this is not a strategy but some general information... I would at least say sometimes but Expand...not always if there are no better documents..

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/AktuelleArtikel/110506_HH_Brasilien_node.html Expand...
Although the information contained in the country pages is varied it is considered to be sufficiently detailed to score on this Expand...indicator because it provides information on both priority themes and sectors. This is consistent with what has been accepted for other donors for this indicator.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://www.bundeshaushalt-info.de/startseite/#/2013/soll/ausgaben/einzelplan.html

Comments

The 2013 budget for AA is published.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

9. Total budget

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found anywhere on the AA website.

Donor Review
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found anywhere on the AA website.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
The overall budget of the AA is actually published: And as we are here no evaluating the ministry as a whole Expand...we can use the general budget of the government... (thopugh I still think aa is not compareable to giz...) Anyway, here ist is: http://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Standardartikel/Themen/Oeffentliche_Finanzen/Bundeshaushalt/Bundeshaushalt_2013/2013-01-08-HH2013-gesamtdatei.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=5 There is also a three year Finanzplan

PWYF Final Assessment
Website
http://www.bundeshaushalt-info.de/startseite/#/2013/soll/ausgaben/einzelplan.html
The 2013 budget for AA is published.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

10. Disaggregated budgets

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found anywhere on the AA website.

Donor Review
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found anywhere on the AA website.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.bundesrechnungshof.de/en/veroeffentlichungen/bemerkungen-jahresberichte-en/dateien/2012-annual-report-on-federal-financial-management-additional-audit-findings-abridged-version

Comments

German Foreign Office covered under the annual Federal Court of Auditors report on federal spending. The information contained, however, is very brief.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

11. Audit

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.bundesrechnungshof.de/en/veroeffentlichungen/bemerkungen-jahresberichte-en/dateien/2012-annual-report-on-federal-financial-management-additional-audit-findings-abridged-version
German Foreign Office covered under the annual Federal Court of Auditors report on federal spending. The information contained, however, is very Expand...brief.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.bundesrechnungshof.de/en/veroeffentlichungen/bemerkungen-jahresberichte-en/dateien/2012-annual-report-on-federal-financial-management-additional-audit-findings-abridged-version
German Foreign Office covered under the annual Federal Court of Auditors report on federal spending. The information contained, however, is very Expand...brief.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.bundesrechnungshof.de/en/veroeffentlichungen/bemerkungen-jahresberichte-en/dateien/2012-annual-report-on-federal-financial-management-additional-audit-findings-abridged-version
German Foreign Office covered under the annual Federal Court of Auditors report on federal spending. The information contained, however, is very Expand...brief.

Donor Comments

Basic

Classifications

Financial

Performance

12. Implementer

13. Unique ID

14. Title

15. Description

16. Planned Dates

17. Actual Dates

18. Current Status

19. Contact Details

20. Collaboration Type

21. Flow Type

22. Aid Type

23. Finance Type

24. Sector

25. Sub-national Location

26. Tied Aid Status

33. Overall Cost

34. Planned Expenditure

35. Actual Expenditure

36. Budget Identifier

37. Results

38. Impact Appraisals

39. Conditions

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

12. Implementer

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Yes but not always. Because not all projects are published

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other Expand...donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Unique ID is not published for AA funded projects listed on the GIZ site.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

13. Unique ID

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
Project links: http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36562.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/29178.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/de/30771.htm Expand...
The AA website has some brief information on its humanitarian aid work in Afghanistan which was its largest ODA recipient in Expand...2011 according to OECD DAC's CRS data. It is not possible to determine an overview of all AA funded activities in Afghanistan from this page. We then tried looking for activity level information on China which was the second largest ODA recipient. The AA website had no country page for China at the time of conducting the search. Next, we tried looking for information on AA activities on the BMZ and GIZ site. No relevant activity information was found on the BMZ site. The GIZ site had four activities that listed AA as one of the commissioning agencies. For the fifth activity, we randomly selected an AA project in Sudan being implemented by GIZ. These activities have been used to assess whether information items are 'always' published. AA to clarify where comprehensive activity level information might be found. The links for the projects assessed in the survey are provided in the evidence box.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
Project links: http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36562.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/29178.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/de/30771.htm Expand...
The AA website has some brief information on its humanitarian aid work in Afghanistan which was its largest ODA recipient in Expand...2011 according to OECD DAC's CRS data. It is not possible to determine an overview of all AA funded activities in Afghanistan from this page. We then tried looking for activity level information on China which was the second largest ODA recipient. The AA website had no country page for China at the time of conducting the search. Next, we tried looking for information on AA activities on the BMZ and GIZ site. No relevant activity information was found on the BMZ site. The GIZ site had four activities that listed AA as one of the commissioning agencies. For the fifth activity, we randomly selected an AA project in Sudan being implemented by GIZ. These activities have been used to assess whether information items are 'always' published. AA to clarify where comprehensive activity level information might be found. The links for the projects assessed in the survey are provided in the evidence box.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
it is kind of difficult to evaluate the AA but not the BMZ. AA is actually not compareable to giz and Expand...KfW AA uses giz and THW as implementing agencies - maybe THW (Technisches Hilfswerk) might be compareable to giz.... and better to rate...

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Unique ID is not published for AA funded projects listed on the GIZ site.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

14. Title

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Not always only for the projects that are there.

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other Expand...donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

15. Description

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website have some descriptive information.

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website have some descriptive information.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
But only sometimes.

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other Expand...donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Information on overall term is provided. This is assumed to indicate the planned dates. Only year, however, is provided. Both month and year are required to score on this indicator.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

16. Planned dates

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Information on overall term is provided. This is assumed to indicate the planned dates. Only year, however, is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Information on overall term is provided. This is assumed to indicate the planned dates. Only year, however, is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Information on overall term is provided. This is assumed to indicate the planned dates. Only year, however, is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Only one set of dates found. These are assumed to be the planned dates. Regardless, only year is provided. Both month and year are required to score on this indicator.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

17. Actual dates

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Only one set of dates found. These are assumed to be the planned dates. Regardless, only year is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Only one set of dates found. These are assumed to be the planned dates. Regardless, only year is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Only one set of dates found. These are assumed to be the planned dates. Regardless, only year is provided. Both month Expand...and year are required to score on this indicator.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf

Comments

Not explicitly published for the projects assessed. Moreover, the project document for the Flying Safely project (one of the activities assessed) which has an overall term of 2009-2014 includes the following sentence "Status as at December 2011". See last page on the second link

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

18. Current Status

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
Not explicitly published for the projects assessed. Moreover, the project document for the Flying Safely project (one of the activities assessed) Expand...which has an overall term of 2009-2014 includes the following sentence "Status as at December 2011". See last page on the second link

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
Not explicitly published for the projects assessed. Moreover, the project document for the Flying Safely project (one of the activities assessed) Expand...which has an overall term of 2009-2014 includes the following sentence "Status as at December 2011". See last page on the second link

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
Not explicitly published for the projects assessed. Moreover, the project document for the Flying Safely project (one of the activities assessed) Expand...which has an overall term of 2009-2014 includes the following sentence "Status as at December 2011". See last page on the second link

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf

Comments

Although the reviewer's feedback is valid, in order to be consistent with what we have accepted for other donors, this information is considered to be 'always published' even though it is a general contact point.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

19. Contact details

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
There are generic AA contact details which can be accessed from the AA Afghanistan page. Contact details are also listed in Expand...project documents.

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
There are generic AA contact details which can be accessed from the AA Afghanistan page. Contact details are also listed in Expand...project documents.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Yes bit when there are not always project descriptions than there are not always contact details. fe: http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Minenraeumen/Minen-Afghanistan_node.html I am not sure Expand...I would say "always" I would prefer sometimes.

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html http://www.giz.de/Themen/en/dokumente/giz2011-air-traffic-control-afghanistan-en.pdf
Although the reviewer's feedback is valid, in order to be consistent with what we have accepted for other donors, this information Expand...is considered to be 'always published' even though it is a general contact point.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html

Comments

Based on information available on the AA website, humanitarian aid is provided both bilaterally and multilaterally. However this information is not stated explicitly per activity

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

20. Collaboration Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html
Based on information available on the AA website, humanitarian aid is provided both bilaterally and multilaterally. However this information is not Expand...stated explicitly per activity.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html
Based on information available on the AA website, humanitarian aid is provided both bilaterally and multilaterally. However this information is not Expand...stated explicitly per activity.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/Aussenpolitik/HumanitaereHilfe/Afghanistan_node.html
Based on information available on the AA website, humanitarian aid is provided both bilaterally and multilaterally. However this information is not Expand...stated explicitly per activity

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

It is likely that most of the funding is ODA. This is not however stated per activity or anywhere on the website as the default flow type.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

21. Flow Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
It is likely that most of the funding is ODA. This is not however stated per activity or anywhere on the Expand...website as the default flow type.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
It is likely that most of the funding is ODA. This is not however stated per activity or anywhere on the Expand...website as the default flow type.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
It is likely that most of the funding is ODA. This is not however stated per activity or anywhere on the Expand...website as the default flow type.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/475722/publicationFile/5122/Humanit%C3%A4reHilfederBundesregierung2007.pdf

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach detailed in the scoring guidelines for this indicator, the response has been changed to 'not published' as a single aid type does not apply to all projects funded by AA. It is not clear whether activities are for example, budget support, pooled funds, project-type interventions, experts, administrative costs, etc.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

22. Aid Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Pdf
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/475722/publicationFile/5122/Humanit%C3%A4reHilfederBundesregierung2007.pdf
Aid type stated in the Federal Government Humanitarian Aid document available on the AA site. On page 2, it is stated Expand...that "...Federal Government the Federal Foreign Office is responsible for humanitarian assistance. It funds emergency and disaster aid, in particular also help for refugees and internally-displaced persons."

Donor Review
Always
Pdf

PWYF Review
Always
Pdf
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/475722/publicationFile/5122/Humanit%C3%A4reHilfederBundesregierung2007.pdf
Aid type stated in the Federal Government Humanitarian Aid document available on the AA site. On page 2, it is stated Expand...that "...Federal Government the Federal Foreign Office is responsible for humanitarian assistance. It funds emergency and disaster aid, in particular also help for refugees and internally-displaced persons."

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
I am not sure the quoted line is enough to qualify the aid type as always published... The document states also: Expand... The Gov- ernment does not carry out aid projects itself, but supports NGOs, the UN aid organizations (e.g. UNHCR, WFP, UNICEF) and the International Committee of the Red Cross. This is at least two aid types: multilateral and project intervention.

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/475722/publicationFile/5122/Humanit%C3%A4reHilfederBundesregierung2007.pdf
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach detailed in the scoring guidelines for this indicator, Expand...the response has been changed to 'not published' as a single aid type does not apply to all projects funded by AA. It is not clear whether activities are for example, budget support, pooled funds, project-type interventions, experts, administrative costs, etc.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Can be derived in a few cases, but not stated explicitly for each project.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

23. Finance Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
Can be derived in a few cases, but not stated explicitly for each project.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
Can be derived in a few cases, but not stated explicitly for each project.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Can be derived in a few cases, but not stated explicitly for each project.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer on other indicators (results, descriptions, title, implementer and objectives), the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found. This is consistent with the approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

24. Sector

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html
Activities are listed by sector:

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html
Activities are listed by sector:

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/358.html
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer on other indicators (results, descriptions, title, implementer and objectives), the response has been Expand...changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found. This is consistent with the approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm

Comments

This information can be found in he project profiles on the GIZ website. However it is often stated incidentally in the description and is not explicitly specified.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

25. Sub-national location

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm
This information can be found in he project profiles on the GIZ website. However it is often stated incidentally in the Expand...description and is not explicitly specified.

Donor Review
Sometimes
Website

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm
This information can be found in he project profiles on the GIZ website. However it is often stated incidentally in the Expand...description and is not explicitly specified.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36366.htm
This information can be found in he project profiles on the GIZ website. However it is often stated incidentally in the Expand...description and is not explicitly specified.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

No statement found clarifying explicitly whether AA aid is tied or untied. The information could not be found for the projects assessed.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

26. Tied Aid Status

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
No statement found clarifying explicitly whether AA aid is tied or untied. The information could not be found for the projects Expand...assessed.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
No statement found clarifying explicitly whether AA aid is tied or untied. The information could not be found for the projects Expand...assessed.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
No statement found clarifying explicitly whether AA aid is tied or untied. The information could not be found for the projects Expand...assessed.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/617534/publicationFile/168411/120516-Dt-Afgh-Partnerschaftsabkommen-Englisch.pdf

Comments

Agreement of bilateral cooperation between the federal government of Germany and the federal government of Afghanistan is published. As per the indicator scoring guidelines, the MoU is checked only for the largest recipient country for each donor organisation.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

27. MoU

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/617534/publicationFile/168411/120516-Dt-Afgh-Partnerschaftsabkommen-Englisch.pdf
Agreement of bilateral cooperation between the federal government of Germany and the federal government of Afghanistan. Development cooperation covered in brief.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/617534/publicationFile/168411/120516-Dt-Afgh-Partnerschaftsabkommen-Englisch.pdf
Agreement of bilateral cooperation between the federal government of Germany and the federal government of Afghanistan. Development cooperation covered in brief.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Did you find MoUs with all countries that the AA is active with?? Or only the one with Afghanisthan??

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/cae/servlet/contentblob/617534/publicationFile/168411/120516-Dt-Afgh-Partnerschaftsabkommen-Englisch.pdf
Agreement of bilateral cooperation between the federal government of Germany and the federal government of Afghanistan is published. As per the Expand...indicator scoring guidelines, the MoU is checked only for the largest recipient country for each donor organisation.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Document

Source

http://www.bmz.de/en/publications/type_of_publication/evaluation/international_joint_evaluations/EvalBerichtHumanitarianAid.pdf

Comments

There is a 2011 join evaluation of of aid provided by AA and BMZ in the period between 2005-2009. No such evaluation covering the period since was found. Furthermore, the 2011 evaluation provides only high level findings, with no information provided on individual projects or activities.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

28. Evaluations

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Document
http://www.bmz.de/en/publications/type_of_publication/evaluation/international_joint_evaluations/EvalBerichtHumanitarianAid.pdf
There is a 2011 join evaluation of of aid provided by AA and BMZ in the period between 2005-2009. No such Expand...evaluation covering the period since was found. Furthermore, the 2011 evaluation provides only high level findings, with no information provided on individual projects or activities.

Donor Review
Sometimes
Document

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Document
http://www.bmz.de/en/publications/type_of_publication/evaluation/international_joint_evaluations/EvalBerichtHumanitarianAid.pdf
There is a 2011 join evaluation of of aid provided by AA and BMZ in the period between 2005-2009. No such Expand...evaluation covering the period since was found. Furthermore, the 2011 evaluation provides only high level findings, with no information provided on individual projects or activities.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Document
http://www.bmz.de/en/publications/type_of_publication/evaluation/international_joint_evaluations/EvalBerichtHumanitarianAid.pdf
There is a 2011 join evaluation of of aid provided by AA and BMZ in the period between 2005-2009. No such Expand...evaluation covering the period since was found. Furthermore, the 2011 evaluation provides only high level findings, with no information provided on individual projects or activities.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Document

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

29. Objectives

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Project profiles on GIZ website provide this information.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Yes but not always...

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Document
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other Expand...donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

30. Budget Docs

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

No evidence found demonstrating that contracts issued by the AA for humanitarian assistance projects are systematically published.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

31. Contracts

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
No evidence found demonstrating that contracts issued by the AA for humanitarian assistance projects are systematically published.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
No evidence found demonstrating that contracts issued by the AA for humanitarian assistance projects are systematically published.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
No evidence found demonstrating that contracts issued by the AA for humanitarian assistance projects are systematically published.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

No information on tenders/bidding or procurement opportunities could be found on the AA website. There is also no information on the website indicating that implementing organisations are responsible for procurement and publishing tenders.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

32. Tenders

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
No information on tenders/bidding or procurement opportunities could be found on the AA website. Donor to clarify whether tenders are published Expand...and if they are, where they can be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
No information on tenders/bidding or procurement opportunities could be found on the AA website. Donor to clarify whether tenders are published Expand...and if they are, where they can be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Maybe the AA does not have tender - because they do not implement project: the giz and the thw and the Expand...ngos do it for the aa

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
No information on tenders/bidding or procurement opportunities could be found on the AA website. There is also no information on the Expand...website indicating that implementing organisations are responsible for procurement and publishing tenders.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

33. Overall cost

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Information not found for the projects assessed.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

34. Planned expenditure

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
Information not found for the projects assessed.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
Information not found for the projects assessed.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Information not found for the projects assessed.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

35. Actual expenditure

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

36. Budget Identifier

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm

Comments

Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

37. Results

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
The projects assessed also contain some brief results information.

Donor Review
Always
Website

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
The projects assessed also contain some brief results information.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
there is no complete project list there can not be always result information...

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.giz.de/themen/en/36570.htm
Based on feedback provided by the independent reviewer and consistent with our approach for assessing comprehensiveness of information published by other Expand...donors, the response has been changed to 'sometimes published' as no comprehensive list of projects funded by AA could be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

38. Impact Appraisals

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

39. Conditions

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document

PWYF Review
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

>