Please note: You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please update to IE10 here to properly experience the ATI website.

30.

Korea – Korean International Cooperation Agency

Poor

ATI_Donor Graph-30

OVERVIEW

Korea is not an IATI signatory but is covered by the Busan common standard commitments, of which IATI is a core component. It has joined OGP but its National Action Plan does not include any commitments specific to aid transparency. KOICA published an implementation schedule for the common standard in August 2013, outlining KOICA’s plans for improvements to its online ODA system by 2015. The plan does not yet explicitly commit to IATI. KOICA’s project database stat.koica.go.kr includes information on KOICA’s aid activities.

 

 

ANALYSIS

KOICA scores 27.9%, placing it in the poor category. Ranked 15th out of 49 bilateral agencies, it is more transparent than most European donors, including traditional donors such as Finland, Spain and Italy. It performs well on organisational-level planning information and the provision of project documents. It performs less strongly on the systematic provision of basic information, classifications and financial data for its activities. Although KOICA has a project database with information on many of its activities, information on current projects was unfortunately not available at the time of data collection, resulting in KOICA’s poor performance at the activity level.  Of the 22 indicators that take format into account, only one – disaggregated budgets – is published in a machine-readable format, in Korea’s Forward Spending Survey report to the OECD DAC.

RECOMMENDATIONS

  • Korea should join IATI and begin publishing in 2014 to meet its Busan commitments. KOICA should work with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Strategy and Finance (Economic Development Cooperation Fund) to produce an ambitious implementation schedule by early 2014 that aims to fully implement the IATI standard by the end of 2015.
  • KOICA should ensure that information on all its aid activities on its projects database is up to date.
  • Korea should update its OGP National Action Plan to include commitments to aid transparency and implementing IATI.

Close

DONOR PROFILE

First published to IATI:

N/A

Data was found in the following formats where relevant:

0% IATI

5% CSV/Excel

18% PDF

32% Website

45% Not Published

SCORING

27.94%

COMMITMENT TO
AID TRANSPARENCY:

4.44/10

PUBLICATION
ORGANISATION LEVEL:

10.88/25

PUBLICATION
ACTIVITY LEVEL:

12.62/65

Commitment

1. FOIA

2. Implementation Schedules

3. Accessibility

Publication Status
Source

http://www.rti-rating.org/methodology.php

Comments

Korea''s Global RTI rating score is 84. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using the following scale: 1 - 60: 33, 61- 90: 66, 91 - 150: 100. The Global RTI rating is the data source for this indicator for all bilateral government donors. We consider the methodology to be robust and comparable across different laws. More information on the RTI rating can be found in the link provided alongside.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

1. FOIA

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php
Korea''s Global RTI rating score is 84. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using Expand...the following scale: 1 - 60: 33, 61- 90: 66, 91 - 150: 100

Donor Review
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/country_data.php
1. Regarding the level of relevant law or regulation on information disclosure, if ATI is rating agency by agency, national law Expand...is not closely to the agency's disclosure policy on aid activities, rather it is only a way to see the overall domestic legal framework for the public agencies. -> We recommend to consider evaluating disclosure policies or strategy of the agency being evaluated. 2. In order to evaluate at the national law or policy basis, it is doubtable to depend RTI's evaluation mechanism due to several reasons below. -> In case of Korea, Korea Ministry of Government Legislation has published updated Disclosure Law by Public Agencies (recently final version, 2013.3.23, source http://www.law.go.kr/lsSc.do?menuId=0&subMenu=1&query=disclosure#liBgcolor0) but RTI is evaluating oldest version which is published in 1996. In this way it is difficult to trust RTI's evaluation results. In addition, it is hard to understand how RTI is scoring a law by categories, such as if there is special contents, sentences, or standards to measure the quality of different disclosure law from countries at a single standard.

PWYF Review
http://www.rti-rating.org/methodology.php
The Global RTI rating is the data source for this indicator for all bilateral government donors. We consider the methodology to Expand...be robust and comparable across different laws. More information on the RTI rating can be found in the link provided alongside.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
The Global RTI rating is the data source for this indicator for all bilateral government donors. We consider the methodology to Expand...be robust and comparable across different laws. More information on the RTI rating can be found in the link provided alongside.

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
http://www.rti-rating.org/methodology.php
Korea''s Global RTI rating score is 84. Score conversion from total score on Global RTI rating to Index points done using Expand...the following scale: 1 - 60: 33, 61- 90: 66, 91 - 150: 100. The Global RTI rating is the data source for this indicator for all bilateral government donors. We consider the methodology to be robust and comparable across different laws. More information on the RTI rating can be found in the link provided alongside.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://tracker.publishwhatyoufund.org/plan/organisations/

Comments

Based on Publish What You Fund's analysis of IATI/Common Standard implementation schedules. Korea's implementation schedule does not indicate by when it will start publishing to IATI.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

2. Implementation schedules

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
http://www.oecd.org/dac/aid-architecture/Korea_Implementation%20Schedule%20for%20the%20common%20standard.XLSX
Korea's implementation schedule does not indicate by when it will start publishing to IATI.

Donor Review
Document
http://www.oecd.org/dac/aid-architecture/Korea_Implementation%20Schedule%20for%20the%20common%20standard.XLSX
KOICA has delivered the document to MOFA in November 2011, and will be able to see on the OECD website soon.

PWYF Review

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
http://tracker.publishwhatyoufund.org/plan/organisations/
Based on Publish What You Fund's analysis of IATI/Common Standard implementation schedules. Korea's implementation schedule does not indicate by when it Expand...will start publishing to IATI.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://stat.koica.go.kr:8077/komis/jsptemp/ps/stat_index.jsp

Comments

The KOICA portal scores for free bulk export and detailed disaggregated data. However there is no information on the license. Open license is not the same as public access.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

3. Accessibility

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Document
http://stat.koica.go.kr:8077/komis/jsptemp/ps/stat_index.jsp
Portals are scored using three criteria: 1) the portal allows free, bulk export of data; 2) it contains detailed disaggregated data; Expand...3) the data is published under an open licence. The KOICA portal scores for free bulk export and detailed disaggregated data.

Donor Review
Document
http://stat.koica.go.kr:8077/komis/jsptemp/ps/stat_index.jsp
Full Score KOICA stat website is a free, bulk export data system. and provides public access to the all stat of KOICA's Expand...activities. Also the data is available in Excel format.

PWYF Review
The KOICA portal scores for free bulk export and detailed disaggregated data. However there is no information on the license. Open Expand...license is not the same as public access.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
The KOICA portal scores for free bulk export and detailed disaggregated data. However there is no information on the license. Open Expand...license is not the same as public access.

PWYF Final Assessment
Document
http://stat.koica.go.kr:8077/komis/jsptemp/ps/stat_index.jsp
The KOICA portal scores for free bulk export and detailed disaggregated data. However there is no information on the license. Open Expand...license is not the same as public access.

Donor Comments

Planning

Financial

4. Organisation Strategy

5. Annual Report

6. Allocation Policy

7. Procurement Policy

8. Country Strategy

9. Total Budget

10. Disaggregated Budgets

11. Audit

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://koica.go.kr/download/20102015koicaplan.pdf

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

4. Organisation strategy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://koica.go.kr/download/20102015koicaplan.pdf

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://koica.go.kr/download/20102015koicaplan.pdf

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/upload/pr/annual/2011annual_e.pdf

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

5. Annual report

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/upload/pr/annual/2011annual_e.pdf

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/upload/pr/annual/2011annual_e.pdf

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/download/koicaplan2013.pdf

Comments

KOICA's annual budget distribution plan is published on the website

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

6. Allocation policy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
N/A

Donor Review
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/download/koicaplan2013.pdf
KOICA's annual budget distribution plan is published on the website

PWYF Review
Always
Document
Response changed to 'always published' based on evidence provided by the donor.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/download/koicaplan2013.pdf
KOICA's annual budget distribution plan is published on the website

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

7. Procurement policy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/area/index.html

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

8. Country strategy

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/area/index.html

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/area/index.html

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html

Comments

Budget for 2013 available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

9. Total budget

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html
Korean aid including KOICA has no forward budget process.

Donor Review
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/download/koicaplan2013.pdf http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html
Korean national budget is planned by a year, hence KOICA is always publishing annual plan for total annual budget expenditure at Expand...the beginning of the year.

PWYF Review
Not published

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html
Budget for 2013 available.

Donor Comments

Publication Status
Source

http://www.oecd.org/dac/aid-architecture/CRS%20FSS%20data%20online%20-%202013%20Survey.xlsx

Comments

Budget for three years available through the CRS ++ FSS data.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

10. Disaggregated budgets

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html
Korean aid including KOICA has no forward budget process.

Donor Review
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/download/koicaplan2013.pdf http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/odareport/plan/index.html
Same as above, KOICA has one year budget distribution plan, and we have published annual plan for budget distribution by sectors, Expand...regions, countries, and activities.

PWYF Review
Not published

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Machine readable
http://www.oecd.org/dac/aid-architecture/CRS%20FSS%20data%20online%20-%202013%20Survey.xlsx
Budget for three years available through the CRS ++ FSS data.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/notice/1260192_2925.html

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

11. Audit

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/notice/1260192_2925.html

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/intro/notice/1260192_2925.html

Donor Comments

Basic

Classifications

Financial

Performance

12. Implementer

13. Unique ID

14. Title

15. Description

16. Planned Dates

17. Actual Dates

18. Current Status

19. Contact Details

20. Collaboration Type

21. Flow Type

22. Aid Type

23. Finance Type

24. Sector

25. Sub-national Location

26. Tied Aid Status

33. Overall Cost

34. Planned Expenditure

35. Actual Expenditure

36. Budget Identifier

37. Results

38. Impact Appraisals

39. Conditions

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Comments

The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012. This webpage shows which organization receiving funding for an activity.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

12. Implementer

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp
This webpage shows which organization finally received funding for an activity

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/ http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Data is available on stat database in Excel or either HWP format.

PWYF Review
Always
Website
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement of being current data. Expand...It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to Expand...be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012. This webpage shows which organization receiving funding for an activity.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

13. Unique ID

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
This website doesn't provide a system which allows each activity to be searched by a code or project ID(Number). A project Expand...number for an activity is not clearly stated on the webpage.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
On the stat page, you can search project by country, sector, or other policy markers, and when you open a single Expand...project information, you can see the project ID. (In addition, it's unsure if easy to build a system that can be searched by a project number, which all different countries have different coding system under the circumstances where unified or coherent system for designing project ID does not exist, neither created by IATI)

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not Expand...meet the requirement of being current data. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
each activity has project number, but it is not searched by the number. the system is not aligned

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not Expand...meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html

Comments

The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

14. Title

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Data is available on stat database in Excel format

PWYF Review
Always
Website
This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not Expand...meet the requirement of being current data. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to Expand...be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html

Comments

HWP files are semi-structured (like MS Word documents) and therefore not machine readable

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

15. Description

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://www.koica.go.kr/ICSFiles/artimage/2013/06/12/cko204_1/save_icon_hwp.gif
Description information is available in HWP file.

PWYF Review
Always
Website
HWP files are semi-structured (like MS Word documents) and therefore not machine readable

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html
HWP files are semi-structured (like MS Word documents) and therefore not machine readable

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Pdf

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Response changed to 'always published' in pdf format based on reviewer feedback.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

16. Planned dates

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/type/health/1208557_1583.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/governance/index.html
Same as 2012. In the Korean website, a few have no planned dates. e.g. activities under health sector

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/ http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Data is available on stat database in Excel format

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Website
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement of being current data. Expand...It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
planned date is stated on the pdf file, but it is not aligned with the info on the webpage. This is Expand...why I was choosing 'sometimes'. If scoring decisions are made with the pdf file, it could be 'always published'

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Pdf
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Response changed to 'always published' in pdf format based on reviewer feedback.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

17. Actual dates

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Sometimes
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Data is available on stat database in Excel format, if recorded.

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement of being current data. Expand...It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
According to the stat, dates are stated, but I am not sure if it is actual date or planned date. I Expand...captured the website and send it to you for your understanding.

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to Expand...be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Projects currently under implementation can be searched through the website. But, it's hard to find an activity that is finished or cancelled. More detailed status info needs to be provided on each activity.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

18. Current Status

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/type/education/1208554_1581.html http://www.koica.go.kr/program/type/governance/1208560_1584.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/governance/index.html http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html Expand...
Projects currently under implementation can be searched through the website. But, it's hard to find an activity that is finished or Expand...cancelled. More detailed status info needs to be provided on each activity.

Donor Review
Sometimes
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
You can find the list of on-going project for 2013 on this webpage, but the system does not provide easy-to-search service Expand...by activities

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Website

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Projects currently under implementation can be searched through the website. But, it's hard to find an activity that is finished or Expand...cancelled. More detailed status info needs to be provided on each activity.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Format changed to 'website' based on reviewer comments.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

19. Contact details

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Machine readable
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Contact information as well as details and is included in the attached file on the webpage, which has current information on Expand...each activity KOICA does.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable

PWYF Review
Always
Website
Independent reviewer to confirm whether this should be website format or machine-readable format.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
It should be website, because it's uploaded with pdf which is not machine readable format. answer needs to be changed.

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Format changed to 'website' based on reviewer comments.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information needs to be explicitly stated for each individual project or activity.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

20. Collaboration Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Available through the projects database.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
Independent reviewer to check if collaboration type for current projects is published on the Stat database or any other source.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
collaboration type at per activity is not mentioned in this stat database. but, in country strategy paper there's a comment that Expand...which percent of aid to each country would be bilateral or multilateral. so I am wondering if it is taken as qualified.

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This information needs to be explicitly stated for each individual project or activity.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/history/index.html

Comments

All aid is ODA.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

21. Flow Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/history/index.html
all aid is ODA

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Data is available on stat database in Excel format

PWYF Review
Always
Website
The information on stat database does not meet the requirement for the data to be current as the latest information available Expand...is for 2011.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/history/index.html
All aid is ODA.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Aid type needs to be explicitly stated for each individual project or activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

22. Aid Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Available through the projects database

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
Independent reviewer to confirm if aid type for current projects is published on the Stat database or any other source.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
aid type at per activity is not mentioned in this stat database. but, in country strategy paper there's a comment that Expand...which percent of aid to each country would be project, debt relief or humanitarian relief. so I am wondering if it is taken as qualified.

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Aid type needs to be explicitly stated for each individual project or activity. The information on the Stat database runs up Expand...to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Website

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/delivery/index.html

Comments

All aid is in the form of grants.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

23. Finance Type

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/delivery/index.html
all aid is grants

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Data is available on stat database in Excel format

PWYF Review
Always
Website
This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not Expand...meet the requirement of being current data. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/koica/oda/delivery/index.html
All aid is in the form of grants.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Sector information for all current activities is not being published comprehensively. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. Hence the response has been changed to 'not published', consistent with the scoring approach used for other donors for this indicator.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

24. Sector

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://koica.go.kr/program/type/index.html http://stat.koica.go.kr/
On the main homepage, you can see the priority sectors KOICA works in, and on the STAT homepage, you can get Expand...numeric data by sectors and countries.

PWYF Review
Always
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html
This needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not Expand...meet the requirement of being current data. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Sector information for all current activities is not being published comprehensively. The information on the Stat database runs up to Expand...2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index. Hence the response has been changed to 'not published', consistent with the scoring approach used for other donors for this indicator.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Pdf

Source

No data available.

Comments

Response changed to 'always published' in pdf format based on reviewer feedback.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

25. Sub-national location

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Website
http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/education/index.html http://www.koica.go.kr/english/aid/governance/index.html http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html Expand...
On the webpage, most of activities are specified with their national geographic locations, but a few has only sub-national location. But Expand...the document(3rd URL) has info on sub-national location for each activity, which leads that info on webpage was not updated and aligned with the document.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/ http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Data is available on stat database in Excel format on the project information. Also, given information by ODA Watch is incorrect since Expand...we have outdated information on English webpage, so the information should be different from the updated one for 2013 in Korean.

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Website
Sub-national location needs to be stated per activity. The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does Expand...not meet the requirement of being current data. It does not cover projects that started on or after 2012. Independent reviewer to confirm if updated KOICA webpage for 2013 contains information on current activities (including information on sub-national location.)

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
sub-national location is stated on the pdf file, but it is not aligned with the info on the webpage. This is Expand...why I was choosing 'sometimes'. If scoring decisions are made with the pdf file, it could be 'always published'

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Pdf
Response changed to 'always published' in pdf format based on reviewer feedback.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Pdf

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Information on tied aid status is published for all projects.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

26. Tied Aid Status

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Sometimes
Pdf
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Tied aid status is mentioned in a linked file on the webpage. The document includes current information on each project of Expand...KOICA and a few activities have no info on its tied or untied status . e.g. The Project for the Capacity Building of Korea-Mongolia Technical College in Ulaanbaatar

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
We have updated the linked file

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Pdf
Independent reviewer to confirm if the information is available for all projects assessed. The format of publication would still remain the Expand...same i.e. pdf

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
Information on tied aid status has been updated for all projects. -> should be changed to always published & pdf

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Pdf
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Information on tied aid status is published for all projects.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.mofa.go.kr/incboard/faimsif/treaty_popup.jsp?ITEM_ID=161260FFFCB9988D49256CA20027EF4B&ITEM_PARENT_ID=E52308495349183049256CA200275A1B

Comments

MOU is shared between recipient country and KOICA, and published, but note this isn't provided through KOICA's website. It is available on the Ministry of Foreign affairs website.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

27. MoU

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.mofa.go.kr/incboard/faimsif/treaty_popup.jsp?ITEM_ID=161260FFFCB9988D49256CA20027EF4B&ITEM_PARENT_ID=E52308495349183049256CA200275A1B Expand...
MOU is shared between recipient country and KOICA, and published, but not isn't provided through KOICA's website. It is available on Expand...the Ministry of Foreign affairs website.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.mofa.go.kr/incboard/faimsif/treaty_popup.jsp?ITEM_ID=161260FFFCB9988D49256CA20027EF4B&ITEM_PARENT_ID=E52308495349183049256CA200275A1B Expand...
MOU is shared between recipient country and KOICA, and published, but note this isn't provided through KOICA's website. It is available Expand...on the Ministry of Foreign affairs website.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

28. Evaluations

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/search/media/img/CAT000000035772?metsno=000000011477&fileid=M000000011477_FILE000002 http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html Expand...

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Objectives for current activities are included in this Korean version doc attached webpage.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

29. Objectives

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Objectives for current activities are included in this Korean version doc attached webpage.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Objectives for current activities are included in this Korean version doc attached webpage.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html

Comments

Budget of each activity is provided on the linked document

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

30. Budget Docs

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Budget of each activity is provided on the linked document

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Budget of each activity is provided on the linked document

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

31. Contracts

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Document
Un-publish contract document with companies according to the domestic law which regulates not to open the document to the public to Expand...secure the information of private contractors. (Information Disclosure Law by Public Agencies)

PWYF Review
Not published
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Document
This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Comments

No data available.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

32. Tenders

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://ebid.koica.go.kr/indexx.jsp

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

33. Overall cost

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Available through the project database

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
Independent reviewer to confirm if overall cost for current projects is published on the Stat database or any other source.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
the overall cost mentioned on the stat database

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
The information on the Stat database runs up to 2011 and therefore does not meet the requirement for the information to Expand...be current in order to be taken into consideration for the Index.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Planned expenditure detailing how the overall budget will be spent over the life of the activity needs to be published for all activities. This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

34. Planned expenditure

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Forward expenditure planned for each coming year is not published.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/business/project/1208623_1783.html
Planned expenditure or budget commitment is found in the given document by projects.

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
`
Independent reviewer to review the evidence and confirm whether information is published.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree
it has total budget for each activity for expected years. e.g. Modernizing administration activity in Nepal. '5 million dollars' for Expand...2011-2013 I am not sure if it is qualified as planned expenditure

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Planned expenditure detailing how the overall budget will be spent over the life of the activity needs to be published for Expand...all activities. This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

Actual expenditures are different from the overall or total cost of the activity. The total activity cost is captured in the "overall cost" indicator. Actual expenditures refer to how the total sum was disbursed over the lifetime of the activity. This is particularly relevant where activities last for several years. This information could not be found.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

35. Actual expenditure

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
The expenditure is not on a per-transaction basis.

Donor Review
Always
Machine readable
http://stat.koica.go.kr/
Though our system is not publishing as per-transaction basis due to the technical limitation, however, still we have the total sum Expand...of expenditure by project, which can still be fairly evaluated to see the expenditure for each project.

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
Actual expenditures are different from the overall or total cost of the activity. The total activity cost is captured in the Expand..."overall cost" indicator. Actual expenditures refer to how the total sum was disbursed over the lifetime of the activity. This is particularly relevant where activities last for several years.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
Actual expenditures are different from the overall or total cost of the activity. The total activity cost is captured in the Expand..."overall cost" indicator. Actual expenditures refer to how the total sum was disbursed over the lifetime of the activity. This is particularly relevant where activities last for several years. This information could not be found.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Not Published

Source

No data available.

Comments

This information could not be found. An international coding system is currently being piloted by IATI publishers. KOICA could also use this system.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

36. Budget Identifier

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Not published
N/A
This information could not be found.

Donor Review
Not published
Not published
We wonder if KOICA can make single Identifier without agreement with other donor agencies to have coherent coding system for each Expand...recipient country. This indicator rather should be international based task.

PWYF Review
Not published
Not published
An international coding system is currently being piloted by IATI publishers. KOICA could also use this system.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Not published
Not published
This information could not be found. An international coding system is currently being piloted by IATI publishers. KOICA could also use Expand...this system.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Pdf

Source

http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html

Comments

Evaluation reports are uploaded for activities up to 2012.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

37. Results

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Pdf
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html
Evaluation reports are uploaded for activities up to 2012.

Donor Review
Always
Pdf
This is published document, which needs to be protected from changes. This indicator should be evaluated as document as other indicators for Expand...document

PWYF Review
Always
Pdf

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Pdf
http://www.koica.go.kr/program/evaluation/report/report1/1306991_2556.html
Evaluation reports are uploaded for activities up to 2012.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Sometimes

Format: Document

Source

http://lib.koica.go.kr/searchS/koz/result?st=SUBJ&sNo=0&sq=A1

Comments

Sometimes published. Impact appraisals need to be made available for user groups such as recipient country governments or citizens who are outside South Korea. Response changed to sometimes.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

38. Impact Appraisals

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Not published
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/search/detail/CATKOZ000000035723?mainLink=/searchS/koz&briefLink=/searchS/koz/result?sNo=0_A_sq=A1_A_st=SUBJ Expand...
Feasibility study reports are uploaded on the KOICA website, but it cannot be downloaded.

Donor Review
Always
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/searchS/koz/result?st=SUBJ&sNo=0&sq=A1
There are several feasibility study reports, and some are available to download and the others are open for public at the Expand...KOICA library in hard copy.

PWYF Review
Sometimes
Document
Sometimes published. Impact appraisals need to be made available for user groups such as recipient country governments or citizens who are Expand...outside South Korea. Response changed to sometimes.

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Sometimes
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/searchS/koz/result?st=SUBJ&sNo=0&sq=A1
Sometimes published. Impact appraisals need to be made available for user groups such as recipient country governments or citizens who are Expand...outside South Korea. Response changed to sometimes.

Donor Comments

Publication Status

Always

Format: Document

Source

http://lib.koica.go.kr/search/media/img/CAT000000035864?metsno=000000011508&fileid=M000000011508_FILE000002

Comments

Record of Discussions is included in final report. See pp 107~117.

Click here for indicator definition
Click here to view history

39. Conditions

Stage

Status

Format

Source

Comments

Researcher
Always
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/search/media/img/CAT000000035864?metsno=000000011508&fileid=M000000011508_FILE000002
Record of Discussions is included in final report. 107~117pp on this document.

Donor Review
Always
Document

PWYF Review
Always
Document

Independent Reviewer
Disagree

PWYF Final Assessment
Always
Document
http://lib.koica.go.kr/search/media/img/CAT000000035864?metsno=000000011508&fileid=M000000011508_FILE000002
Record of Discussions is included in final report. See pp 107~117.

Donor Comments

>